
After a wound heals, most people are left with a relatively flat scar; some develop noticeably raised, red, itchy scars that may even grow larger than the original wound area. Such cases are often loosely called “keloids,” but clinically it is necessary to distinguish between at least two common types of raised scars: keloid and hypertrophic scar. Although the two sometimes look quite similar, their course and treatment needs differ, and it is not advisable to rub them or try unproven home remedies.
Key Takeaways: A keloid continues to grow beyond the original wound borders; a hypertrophic scar mostly stays within the boundaries of the wound and may gradually flatten over time. Triggers are often related to skin injury, surgery, piercings, severe acne, or wound tension. When itching, pain, restricted movement, or noticeable scar enlargement occurs, consulting a dermatologist for evaluation is recommended. Home care focuses on protecting the wound and avoiding unnecessary trauma; any injections, laser therapy, surgery, or pressure garments/devices must be individually planned by a physician based on the anatomical site, skin tone, and past response, with no guarantee against recurrence.
What Is the Difference Between a Keloid and a Hypertrophic Scar?
Both are raised scars formed by excessive proliferation of connective tissue (especially collagen) during the wound repair process, but their appearance and course differ.
| Comparison Point | Hypertrophic Scar | Keloid |
|---|---|---|
| Extent | Usually does not extend beyond the original wound borders | Often grows beyond the boundaries of the original wound |
| Onset | Mostly becomes noticeable within a few weeks after injury | May appear slowly months later and can continue to enlarge gradually |
| Changes Over Time | Has a chance to gradually flatten and become less noticeable | Usually does not regress on its own to become “barely visible” |
| Common Concerns | Red, firm, itchy, tight | Reddish-purple, firm, itchy, or painful; large lesions may affect movement or appearance |
The main distinction is this: the thickening of a hypertrophic scar generally remains confined to the original wound area, whereas keloid scar tissue often expands outward beyond the original wound margins. However, in the clinic, the two are sometimes difficult to tell apart at a glance, especially in the early stages; a physician will judge based on medical history and appearance, considering a biopsy only in a few cases to rule out other skin lesions.
Important reminder: Not all raised scars are keloids. Depressed acne scars, surgical suture scars, and post-burn contracture scars also follow different management principles; if your main concern is depressed scars left by acne, you can refer separately to the clinic’s existing article, “What Are the Types of Acne Scars? (in Chinese),” which is not the same condition as the “raised excessive scarring” discussed in this article.
Why Do They Form, and Which Body Areas Are Most Common?
The exact mechanism is still under investigation, but it can generally be understood as dysregulated wound repair signaling that leads to elevated production of collagen and other extracellular matrix components. Common associated situations include:
- Trauma, surgical incisions, burns, and scalds
- Piercings (such as ear piercings)
- Severe acne, folliculitis, or other infected wounds
- A wound that reopens, delayed healing, or areas naturally under higher skin tension
- In a small number of people, excessive scarring may later develop at a vaccination site; however, there are many causes for a post-vaccination lump, and it is not necessarily a scar—diagnosis by a physician is required (see FAQ below)
In terms of body location, the chest, shoulders, upper back, upper arms, and earlobes are common sites; if a scar near a joint becomes thick and tight, it may also restrict movement. Dermatological patient education materials note that individuals with darker skin tones and those with a family history are observed to have a higher risk of keloids, whereas anyone can develop a hypertrophic scar; individual variation is substantial, so one cannot make a self-determination based on skin tone alone.
A small number of people develop keloid-like lesions with almost no identifiable prior trauma; such cases require a physician even more to rule out other skin conditions, and it is not appropriate to assume on your own that “it is definitely a keloid.”
When Should You See a Doctor?
If you notice any of the following, it is advisable to seek an early evaluation at a dermatology clinic rather than repeatedly picking at, abrading, or applying unverified products to the area at home:
- The scar continues to grow, harden, or clearly extend beyond the original wound
- Noticeable itching, stinging, or tenderness that interferes with sleep or daily life
- The scar is near a joint and feels like it is restricting movement
- A globular or expanding raised lump appears after ear piercing, surgery, or acne
- The change in appearance causes you anxiety, and you want to understand what management options can be evaluated
- The firm lump or elevation looks unusual, requiring a physician to rule out other skin tumors, inflammation, or other non-scar lesions
Keloids and hypertrophic scars themselves generally do not turn into skin cancer; however, something that “looks like a keloid” is not necessarily one, so if it has an unusual appearance or changes rapidly, a physician should still determine whether further examination is needed.
How Can You Care for It Day-to-Day? What Should You Avoid Doing Yourself?

Before a wound has fully closed, the priority is proper wound care (cleansing, protection, and changing dressings as directed by a physician), rather than rushing into “scar removal.” While a wound is still scabbed or has broken skin, do not apply occlusive scar sheets on your own to press down on an unhealed wound.
Once the wound has healed, general care measures may include:
- Avoiding repeated friction, scratching, or sun exposure on the area (sun exposure can make discoloration more noticeable)
- When using medical-grade silicone sheets or gels for scar care as recommended by a physician, applying them only to fully closed skin and watching for any skin allergy or breakdown
- If a physician prescribes pressure garments or devices (such as pressure dressings for specific areas or earlobe pressure devices), wearing them as instructed; such methods often require ongoing use, and stopping prematurely on your own may affect the expected outcome, though they are not suitable for everyone
- For individuals prone to keloids, informing the physician in advance about past scarring when discussing non-essential cosmetic piercings, surgical incision sites, and suture tension
Please do not: inject any solutions yourself, freeze or cauterize the area using liquid nitrogen or unverified devices, treat “surgically cutting it out” as a one-and-done fix, or use online folk remedies as a course of treatment. Improper handling can sometimes make the scarring response even harder to control.
How Might a Physician Evaluate and Manage It?

During the evaluation, a physician will typically ask about when the injury occurred, whether the scar is still growing, the severity of itching or pain, past responses to treatment, skin tone and family predisposition, and whether your primary concern is symptoms, mobility, or appearance. Management typically needs to be planned based on the scar type, size, location, and individual risk factors, and a single treatment method is rarely sufficient to resolve the entire problem.
Approaches commonly described in patient education materials that must be performed or guided by a physician include:
- Intralesional injections: Injecting medication directly into the scar tissue, usually aiming to soften and flatten the scar and relieve itching or pain; this generally requires repeated evaluations and injections over a period of time
- Silicone sheets/gels and pressure garments or devices: Used as part of an adjunctive or preventive strategy, especially after surgery or for newly formed raised scars
- Cryotherapy: Applying extreme cold to the scar tissue, commonly used to reduce volume and decrease firmness; suitability depends on scar size and skin tone and requires individual assessment (in individuals with darker skin tones, certain cryotherapy methods carry a risk of leaving pigmentary changes)
- Specific wavelengths of laser or light therapy: Primarily focused on improving the height and color of the scar (such as vascular-related redness) and often combined with other treatments; this likewise requires assessment based on skin tone and scar condition, and is a different procedure from cryotherapy
- Surgical excision: Excising a keloid alone often carries a very high chance of recurrence, and the scar may even grow back larger; if surgery is considered, the physician will typically plan preoperative or postoperative adjunctive measures alongside it to reduce the risk of recurrence
- Other adjunctive options: In a small number of cases, other postoperative adjunctive treatments may be discussed; the pros and cons, follow-up requirements, and individual risks must be explained in person by the physician
Hypertrophic scars sometimes respond relatively better to milder treatment combinations and also have a chance of improving on their own over time; keloids, by contrast, tend to persist and may regrow even after treatment. No single method can guarantee permanent removal or guarantee that recurrence will not happen. Setting goals around relieving symptoms, improving appearance, and maintaining mobility—while accepting that management takes time and multiple adjustments—is a more realistic approach.
If your concern mainly stems from recurrent inflammatory acne, discussing acne care and when to seek medical attention at the same time can also help reduce triggers for new scarring; the raised scars themselves still require separate evaluation.
Recurrence and Expectations: Why Do They So Often “Grow Back After Treatment”?
The challenge with keloids is that the scarring response is easily re-triggered. A surgical incision itself is a new trauma, and tissue repair following injections or cryotherapy can also lead to renewed deposition. For this reason, clinicians commonly emphasize the following:
- Treatment courses usually require a combination of two or more treatment methods along with scheduled follow-up, rather than being completed in a single session
- Even if the scar becomes flatter and softer at the time, you still need to follow instructions for home care and return visits
- Different body sites and different individuals can respond very differently to the same strategy
- Preventing new excessive scarring in the future is sometimes just as important as treating existing lesions (for example, avoiding unnecessary piercings and controlling severe acne)
Setting expectations on “improving symptoms and appearance while reducing the chance of recurrence,” rather than pursuing “guaranteed eradication,” better aligns with current dermatological understanding of this condition.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will a keloid go away on its own?
A hypertrophic scar may gradually flatten over time; a keloid usually does not regress on its own to the point of nearly disappearing. Whether treatment is needed and when to pursue it should still be assessed by a dermatologist based on the actual condition.
Is a firm lump after an ear piercing always a keloid?
Not necessarily. A firm lump on the earlobe may be a keloid or a hypertrophic scar, or it may be persistent inflammation, a foreign body reaction, or another issue. Because these can look similar, they cannot be self-diagnosed; have a physician examine the area before deciding whether and how to treat it, and do not attempt self-injection or self-removal.
Can it simply be removed by surgery alone?
If a keloid is treated with surgical excision alone without accompanying recurrence-prevention measures, it often grows back and may even become larger. Whether surgery is appropriate and which adjunctive measures should be combined must be evaluated individually.
Is a lump on the upper arm after vaccination automatically a keloid?
Not necessarily. Local swelling, induration, inflammation, or other reactions can occur after vaccination, and only a subset of these later develop into excessive scarring (a hypertrophic scar or a keloid). A lump itself cannot be directly equated with a scar and requires a physician’s diagnosis based on timing, appearance, and medical history. If the lump continues to enlarge, causes pain, or affects movement, medical evaluation is recommended; do not squeeze it or apply medications from unknown sources.
Can home silicone sheets replace in-clinic treatment?
Silicone products can serve as an adjunct in some situations, but they cannot replace a physician’s comprehensive evaluation and management plan for a keloid, and they should not be applied to wounds that have not yet healed.
Health Education References
- American Academy of Dermatology — Keloid scars: Overview
- American Academy of Dermatology — Keloid scars: Diagnosis and treatment
- American Academy of Dermatology — Scars: Signs and symptoms
- DermNet — Keloid and hypertrophic scar
This article provides dermatological health education information to support understanding and preparation for medical visits and cannot replace an in-person consultation. Individual diagnosis and management should be determined following evaluation by a qualified physician.